TAPAS.network | 28 January 2022 | Editorial Opinion | Peter Stonham

Change in the Air?

Peter Stonham

AIR TRANSPORT is generally regarded as no Friend of the Planet. On both carbon consumption and emissions grounds, with noise and the impacts of airports thrown in, it is a clear target for Climate Change and sustainability campaigners.

But might there be a better flight path ahead - and could air travel potentially out-green the surface modes of road, and even rail, in some domestic situations?

Planes in the air, like ships in the sea, don’t need expensive tracks to be laid to get from A to B, as do road and rail vehicles. The infrastructure both these ground modes require is both costly, invasive and comes with substantial carbon and resource costs in its construction and maintenance.

Building airports is a simlar problem, but not so much for smaller local ones not required to handle massive numbers of large long haul aircraft with huge loads of passengers to handle and process.
As for the planes themselves, might the end be in sight for the very dirty fossil-fuel era, as work continues apace on both elecrtic and Sustainable Aviation Fuel (SAF) powered aircraft.

Going Zero for aircraft is a diffiicult challenge - but so has been the similar one facing the re- engineering of cars, buses and trucks - and even those trains that are not serving electrified lines.

So if ‘clean’ planes were available, how would the air transport option compare with buses, coaches and trains on individual corridors, taking into account all the elements of their creation and operation? From the terminals and the infrastructure needed to connect origin and destination, to the manufacture of the ‘vehicles’ themselves, and their energy consumption and emissions? Has anyone ever done such a study?

Perhaps such a comparison would thow up situations where the air option was both economically and environmentally the best?

Maybe that would be where there is relatively low demand to meet, across water or difficult terrain, with the need for bridges and tunnels “for the surface alternative, and where smaller aircraft can make shorter trips sustainably (eg by solar or battery power) using simple landing grounds. Grass, and sand on beaches, have done the job well enough in the past - and still do in some places such as the Scottish Western Isles.

quotations 5

Planes in the air, like ships in the sea, don’t need expensive tracks to be laid to get from A to B, as do road and rail vehicles.

This hypothesis is not entirely dependent on pilotless planes - which are certainty being developed and might be a benefit - or far-fetched ideas of personal drone-like air taxis filling the urban skies and raising fears of safety, exacerbated inequality of transport access and intrusion as they seek places to take off and land.

Nor is it a case for the continued inexorable growth of international air travel, prinicipally for personally indulgent leisure puposes.

But putting the ‘air option’ as explored here into the multi-modal domestic transport mix is surely not something to rule out without a serious look. Could electric, or SAF powered eco-friendly planes be one day assessed in the same way as the equivalent buses and trains - with their lack of a track requirement giving them the edge in approriate circumstances?

Over the past few hundred years we became wedded to the idea of creating physical routes by laying down concrete, tarmac and iron and steel to mark out lines on maps that ‘connect’ places. Such infrastucture is obviously still approriate in many situations. But not everywhere that should be connected needs massive ‘infrastructure investment’ to do it. After all, we don’t need netwoks of wires and cables to connect each other by voice and image any more.

Peter Stonham is the Editorial Director of TAPAS Network

This article was first published in LTT magazine, LTT838, 28 January 2022.

d1-20220128
taster
Read more articles by Peter Stonham
Long-term thinking on local public transport finances needed now
THE LATEST post-pandemic support that the Government agreed to provide to local public transport two weeks ago amounts to a further holding operation to the sector’s fragile finances. Without the continuing tranches of such public funding over the past almost three years, it should be acknowledged that things would be in a much worse place than they would have been otherwise. That said, it was already the Government’s agenda to halt continuing declines in levels of bus service and patronage, and instead create a positive climate of the kind set out in the Bus Back Better ambitions document during the Covid-19 pandemic itself.
Uber thinking goes beyond taxis
FROM ITS BEGINNINGS in the early days of the last decade, Uber was clear about its plans for long-term disruption to the transport system - and of a willingness for self-disruption too. Keen observers recognised the company’s long-term goal was more than simply helping users ride in other people’s cars. It sought the eventual ability and role of letting those looking for travel facilities book any option within its app. It was not the only startup with a vision of a fully tech-enabled transportation future of this kind, of course.
Budget thinking could define this Government’s term for transport
SPECULATION IS GROWING about the transport implications of the new Labour government’s first Budget on 30 October. Both prime minister Kier Starmer and Chancellor Rachel Reeves have continued to warn of ‘tough choices’ to address a funding gap which will impact both the government’s tax and spending policies, whilst they talk the language of ‘new priorities’ and more rigorous approaches to meeting objectives and securing value for money from investment.
Read more articles on TAPAS
It’s people driving policy
THE ANNOUNCEMENT of a tough new approach to road investment represents another step in the radical changes that the Welsh Government is making to its transport policies, and in setting a direction which many hope will be taken up elsewhere around the United Kingdom.
Elizabeth line defies elasticity models: modal transfers and generated demand provide new paradigm for high profile changes to network
TAPAS continues its close monitoring of how the new Elizabeth Line is changing transport patterns in London. With new data now available on usage and the origin of passengers, Rhodri Clark examines some surprising outcomes and their potential implications for those planning similar transformational schemes.
Timing is crucial for a launch of road pricing - and might that time be now?
There have been a swathe of reports and articles over recent years campaigning and justifying the need for national road pricing in the UK, but it is critical to get the timing right. It could potentially take around three and a half years to put in place, believes Richard Sallnow. With a new Government in office, might the time to begin that process be now, he wonders? In this third part of his look at the topic he stresses it would require public and private sector collaboration, extensive public engagement and a good dose of political will.