TAPAS.network | 25 March 2022 | Editorial Opinion | Peter Stonham

All change for the trains and buses - but will it deliver?

Peter Stonham

'PUBLIC UTILITY OR PRIVATE ENTERPRISE' is an issue of both very philosophical and practical dimensions

After the Second World War, the 1945 Labour government took the view that the railways should be state owned and run, and nationalised them- and that was how they stayed for Fifty years, under governments of both colours, albeit with not-inconsiderable pruning under the Beeching plan of the early 1960s. That ownership model meant a considerable public body- the British Railways board- was required, not to mention a matching division of people in the controlling government Ministry.

As far as buses were concerned, the post war years saw a mix of public, private and municipal ownership ( in which might be included the London Transport system) until the Labour Government in 1968 setup the National Bus Company to amalgamate the two major Public and Private Groups, to be run as 70-odd local operating subsidiaries; and established the Passenger Transport Executives in the Metropolitan areas to bring together the urban municipal operations there as single entities. Both these new organisations had to be suitably structured and resourced, and supervised under appropriate national and local political control.

That set up was then left alone by successive Governments of both Parties for nearly twenty five years

It took the arrival of The Conservatives under Margaret Thatcher in the 1980s to change virtually all of both of those bus and rail arrangements - first by deregulating and privatising the state and metropolitan authority owned buses, and then privatising the railways too- both trains and track.

Amongst all this upheaval London was given special treatment - with direct government control of a renamed London Transport replacing that by the Greater London Council, and some tinkering with the Underground in terms of introducing private contracts for the track but not the trains, and the opposite for the buses, where the operational assets were sold off to become privately owned contracted service suppliers.

That too was then largely left alone for a quarter of a century by the subsequent Labour and Conservative Governments. Until now.

quotations 5

there is a crucial practical dimension about the newly- emerging situation that must be addressed fast: ensuring the new system is properly resourced and efficiently run.

The Boris Johnson Conservative agenda has proved quite a different one to his predecessors, with the Railways now effectively brought back almost fully under state control, as the franchisees lose their commercial role to become contracted service suppliers; and the majority of the buses are effectively stripped of much of their commercial freedom, to in turn become franchisees to run networks specified by the local transport authorities.

Whilst there is still plenty of scope to argue about the underlying philosophies and the detailed delivery models, there is a crucial practical dimension about the newly- emerging situation that must be addressed fast: ensuring the new system is properly resourced and efficiently run..

Within that challenge is the key matter of how the public sector approaches the task of setting out what it wants both the rail and bus systems to be like, and how they are paid for - something which now clearly falls to the Government for the most part in the case of the railways,( but with quite a lot of devolved responsibility to the nations and regions), and to the Local Transport Authorities in the case of the buses.

It's a big job in both cases, and as yet the outline of how and what will be the 'specified system', and the commercial regime it must work to, is still largely unclear- not to mention the principles, processes and resources that will be needed for the job.

Emerging information in three forms is giving a taste of that substantial challenge.

Firstly, in lauding the recent legal judgment that seems to give Greater Manchester ( and the other metropolitan areas) the go ahead to bring in bus franchising, both Manchester Mayor Andy Burnham and Transport Secretary Grant Shapps have embraced the vision of a locally-specified integrated network with attractive fares - effective commercial responsibility for which will be falling to the Transport Authority, yet with largely undefined resources.

Meanwhile, the continuing tensions between the London Mayor and Shapps over the financial model for London's transport system, in the light of the substantial Government subventions being needed post-Covid, are revealing the kind of detailed workplan that The Dft is now having to write for its effective client in TfL, and the major financial and reporting issues implicit in that regime.

And thirdly, the information just made public in the two new Rail Contracts placed by DfT with Abellio East Anglia and West Midlands Trains, again indicate the tightly defined requirements of the Government- both operational and financial- and the kind of organisation clearly required to now specify and supervise the rail system- presumably involving both the DfT and the new Great British Railways organisation.

There are a lot of challenging issues - and challenging relationships- at stake here. Between Central and Local Government and the operators, and how they define something approaching a shared understanding and vision. This will need to apply both at the top level in regard to policy,, and in the way things happen on the ground around the country - down to where the trains and buses stop, and who looks after the customers waiting there.

After all, this new way of doing things is all being done for everyone's benefit, and not just by people playing politics. Isn't it?

Peter Stonham is the Editorial Director of TAPAS Network

This article was first published in LTT magazine, LTT842, 25 March 2022.

d2-20220516-1
taster
Read more articles by Peter Stonham
Plus ça Change…
THE MESSAGE we are all hearing from the General Election campaign - at least from everyone but the current Government- is that it is time for a change. What isn’t clear, however, is how that change will play out in the real world, and especially in the world of transport, and what it will mean for the activity of those involved at the front line in planning and delivering transport systems and services.
Yes, AVs can have a role - but only where they fit in
AUTOMATED VEHICLES are in the news again - they could hardly not be if Elon Musk is involved. But the Tesla CEO’s launch of his much-fanfared Robotaxi at a glitzy event held at Warner Bros. Studios in Burbank, California complete with dancing Robots was arguably more show than substance. Musk unveiled the Cybercab: a self-driving taxi which has two seats, no steering wheel and no pedals, saying, rather unconvincingly it would be available “before 2027”. “I think it’s going to be a glorious future,” he told the crowd. But glorious for whom, he didn’t amplify.
Travel behaviour change: what’s possible, what works, and what’s needed?
ANYONE CONSIDERING the full range of issues facing our transport system, and how it might best be developed to meet current and future expectations for both what can be realistically supplied, and what patterns and levels of use are possible to cater for sustainably, is likely to at least acknowledge as part of the equation the question of how to encourage and influence travel behaviour.
Read more articles on TAPAS
NTS 2022 records continuing impacts of the Pandemic – but dominance of car still shows through
Travel patterns were dramatically changed by the COVID 19 Pandemic, and the restrictions it brought. The new National Travel Survey results for 2020 show a further revival against the very low trip levels of 2020 and 2021, but still below 2019. John Siraut examines the data, and considers whether it indicates a permanent new position, in which travel activity is lower, and car users and non users have very contrasting types of trip making.
A Tale of Two Spaces: digging into the history of our cities’ historic public squares
City authorities need to ensure their public spaces – of whatever shape and size – play the most beneficial role they can in urban life, says John Dales. Having recently explored two neighbouring spaces in central London, he was struck by their contrasting fortunes and considers what lessons can be learnt from their recent circumstances
Buses: data reveals an unstable and challenging landscape
Tracking bus use has been a significant part of monitoring the impacts of the pandemic, but also the continuing long-term decline in the sector. John Siraut examines the latest annual bus statistics and finds a number of significant regional and local differences, including in the levels of dependence on public funding. He also looks at the amount of concessionary bus travel, the change in fare levels and in drivers wages over the last twenty years.