TAPAS.network | 29 April 2022 | Commentary | John Siraut

Cars, trains, buses and flights: How much do we all spend on transport?

Some fascinating figures are revealed by a look at the transport elements of the ONS weekly Household Spending survey- both the balance of different modal categories, and the change over time. John Siraut here examines the data, and what it tells us about the differences across incomes and age distribution.

THE OFFICE FOR NATIONAL STATISTICS household spending survey provides a detailed snapshot of our spending habits. Figure 1 shows total weekly spending on transport over the last 20 years and as a percentage of total spending. Over that 20-year period, total household expenditure has remained relatively stable. However, the amount spent on transport declined steadily, mainly due to the reducing cost of cars, from nearly £100 a week at the beginning of the Millennium, reaching a low point in 2012 of £71.70. It has risen since then but remains about 20% below its peak. As a percentage of total household spending it has fallen from a high of 17% in 2001 down to 14% now.

Figure 1: Household expenditure on transport in 2019-20 prices.

As figure 2 shows, motor fuel accounts for the largest proportion of weekly transport spending (24%), followed by the purchase of second-hand cars at (18%) which is perhaps surprisingly around twice as much as is spent on the purchase of new cars. Vehicle insurance is also a significant cost, accounting for 12% of transport spend. Public transport on the other hand comes out at just 8% of weekly total transport spending.

Figure 2: Transport spend by category

The average household spend data hides a number of variations when income and age are taken into consideration. Figure 3 shows the percentage of household transport budget spent on; car purchase, fuel, rail and bus fares by household income decile. There are some clear and not surprising trends in the data in relation to public transport. Lower income households spend a higher proportion of their transport budgets on buses, although at just 4% it is still very low. This proportion falls to just 1% for the highest income group. While the proportion of household income spent on rail fares starts to fall as income rises but then rises steeply for the highest income households. However, in aggregate the proportion of household spending on public transport for the highest income households, at 8%, is broadly the same as the lowest income ones. With regard to motoring costs, the highest income groups while spending the highest in absolute terms on purchasing vehicles, as a percentage of total transport expenditure they spend the least. For them, fuel costs which account for over 30% of their transport costs is the largest single item. It is notable that higher income households spend more on fuel than car purchase while for lower income households it tends to be the other way round.

Figure 3: Proportion of household transport budget spent on vehicle purchase, fuel, bus and rail fares by household income decile.

The spending patterns based on age are different again. As table 4 shows, the under 30s spend a higher proportion (and in absolute terms) of their transport budget on public transport, especially rail fares. Vehicle insurance is also a higher cost for this age group than all other age groups.

Motoring expenditure mainly relates to the purchase of vehicles except for the oldest and youngest age groups where fuel accounts for more of their budget.

Figure 4: Proportion of household transport budget spent on vehicle purchase, fuel, bus and rail fares by age of household reference person.

The average household now spends more on air fares (excluding the air fare component of package holidays) than on public transport. Whilst motoring costs account for the vast majority of all households’ transport budgets regardless of income or age.

Statistics available from the ONS Data Set Family spending workbook 1: detailed expenditure and trends.

John Siraut is director of economics at Jacobs.

This article was first published in LTT magazine, LTT844, 29 April 2022.

d5-20220429

taster

Read more articles by John Siraut

Road User Charging – does the switch to electric mean its time has now come?

Last year John Siraut was amongst transport professionals to give evidence to the Transport Select Committee’s Inquiry into Road Pricing. The Committee’s report, just published, comes out strongly in favour of the need to consider a range of options to replace fuel and vehicle excise duties, including charging motorists according to distance driven, vehicle type and the level of congestion. Here John Siraut explores the underlying public policy issues posed by the increasing switch to electric vehicles.

11 February 2022

How sandwich sales have added new insights about current transport and travel trends

Taking the pulse of transport activity in the shorter term is a different challenge to plotting long term modal usage trends - and can potentially benefit from less obvious data sources. John Siraut looks at some new indicators that could be valuable markers in this regard - some that might be unexpected, but revealing alternative measures of transport use.

30 May 2022

What is the impact of the £2 fare cap - and could it change the trajectory of bus use?

The introduction earlier this year of a £2 maximum bus fare in England, and its subsequent extension, has the potential to alter the appeal of bus travel to a small but significant audience, believes John Siraut. He examines who stands to benefit most, what the initial indications of the user response are.

31 October 2023

Read more articles on TAPAS

Bring back SACTRA – it is high time to open up the black box that drives transport policies, not shut down vital discussion

An increasing number of government transport policy documents and supporting technical papers are failing to properly provide for highly necessary discussions about uncertain forecasts and speculative outcomes concerning economic development, climate change and future travel patterns, says David Metz. Too much faith is being placed in the models, with too few challenges provided for decision-making frameworks on which everything relies, he warns, for which an independent view is essential.

David Metz | 23 May 2023

It’s time to re-appraise appraisal, and Wales shows the way

WHAT A CONTRAST IS EMERGING between the Welsh and English approaches to clearly defining the basis upon which future transport investment decisions should sensibly be made. In this LTT issue we examine the Welsh Government’s lucid and accessible set of plans for how schemes should be drawn up and assessed against clearly stated national policy objectives. Meanwhile, the Department for Transport, whose writ now only runs in England on this policy area, has announced a series of esoteric and impenetrable changes to its complex and multi-faceted transport appraisal guidance, still fundamentally based on seeking to predict what the future holds.

Peter Stonham | 5 September 2022

An industrial view of a public policy puzzle

THE LONG-AWAITED report from the group led by Juergen Maier commissioned by Transport Secretary Louise Haigh when in opposition, has come as something of a disappointment to anyone hoping to see the full shape of the new Government’s transport strategy emerging, or even a comprehensive vision for the two subject areas it has specifically addressed - rail and urban transport.

Peter Stonham | 5 September 2024